Tuesday, October 20, 2020

MARX ANDREVOLUTIONARY ORDER

The pH ‘universal indicator’ test to be conducted in this chapteris a little more complex than that carried out in Chapter 1, eventhough it proceeds along similar lines. Here, Marx’s Capital is thewhite paper, so to speak, and Russia turns it reddest, at least inthe end, that is by 1917. But Marx himself shifted his own positionon Russia considerably before his death in 1883, while both beforeand after the Russian Revolution his disciples argued about themessage to be extracted from his teachings. The basic questionswere: was the process described in Capital global or merelyWestern? How long would it take for that process to work itselfout, and for capitalism to be superseded by communism? Then,in particular, to what extent was Russia a full participant in thepassage from feudalism to capitalism and beyond? More certainly,during Marx’s lifetime, the USA was rapidly rising to beconsidered an integral participant in capitalist modernisation, butits ‘alkali’ resisted the overall impact of later Marxist doctrines.The major battles were fought in Soviet Russia, by Lenin, Stalinand Trotsky, whose struggle for the true succession will receiveat least a measure of the attention that it deserves. While non-Bolsheviks also joined in the debate throughout Europe andbeyond, even in Russia a more traditional Western view of worldorder was still in existence, as evidenced in an essay on ‘The NextTask’ by the historian E.V.Tarle. Just as Robespierre provided abridge from Chapter 1 to Chapter 2, Tarle builds another fromChapter 2 to Chapter 3On 17 March 1883, Frederick Engels made his speech at thegraveside of Karl Marx in Highgate cemetery, London. Three daysbefore, ‘the greatest living thinker ceased to think’. And so: ‘Animmeasurable loss has been sustained both by the militantproletariat of Europe and America, and by historical science, inthe death of this man. The gap that has been left by the death ofthis mighty spirit will soon make itself felt.’ For:Just as Darwin discovered the law of evolution in organicnature, so Marx discovered the law of evolution in humanhistory; he discovered the simple fact, hitherto concealedby an overgrowth of ideology, that mankind must first ofall eat and drink, have shelter and clothing, before it canpursue politics, science, religion, art, etc.; and thattherefore the production of the immediate material meansof subsist-ence and consequently the degree of economicdevelopment attained by a given people or during a givenepoch, form the foundation upon which the stateinstitutions, the legal conceptions, the art and even thereligious ideas of the people concerned have beenevolved, and in the light of which these things musttherefore be explained, instead of vice versa as hadhitherto been the case But that was not all: in particular, Marx had discovered the lawof surplus value, ‘the special law of motion governing the present-day capitalist mode of production and the bourgeois society thatthis mode of production has created’. Moreover, the man of sciencewho made independent discoveries in every field that heinvestigated was not even half the man. ‘Science was for Marx ahistorically dynamic, revolutionary force’, and the man himselfwas ‘before all else a revolutionary’, whose real mission was tooverthrow capitalist society and its state institutions, and tocontribute to the liberation of the proletariat. Marx had been thefirst to bring about the proletariat’s consciousness of its ownposition and needs, and for this revolutionary cause, ‘he foughtwith a passion, a tenacity and a success such as few could rival’.While he had encountered much slan-der and opposition, he hadbrushed them aside as though they were cobwebs. He had hardlyone personal enemy, and was ‘beloved, revered and mourned bymillions of revolutionary fellow-workers—from the mines ofSiberia to California, in all parts of Europe and America’. Engelsconcluded: ‘His name will endure through the ages, and so alsowill his work!’1Little more than a century after that ringing declaration, the issueis somewhat in doubt. While the Russian Revolution of October1917 and its aftermath appeared to give fresh emphasis to the wordsof Engels, the August Revolution of 1991 seemed to mark the endof an era in Russia, with the beginning of the end already apparentin Eastern Europe in 1989. This of course was 200 years after theFrench Revolution, whose authenticity was also more than a littlein question in bicentennial analysis. Towards the end of thetwentieth century, then, the cause of revolution looks to be in retreat.We will examine that subject in due course in Chapter 5. Here,in Chapter 2, we will attempt our own appraisal of aspects of thelife and works of Karl Marx, as well as making some observationsabout the revolutions, from 1789 in France to 1917 in Russia, andbeyond. In this exercise, we shall not forget Marx’s own words,especially

CONSTITUTION AND REVOLUTION: BURKE ANDROBESPIERRE

As he left office, Washington hoped that his policy of neutralitywould be followed, as well as the rest of his advice. In fact, theimpact of the French Revolution and accompanying wars was tolead to strains on good order of a kind even greater than those ofthe mid-1790s. On the other hand, there were observations of amore lasting value in his Farewell Address, which was to bediscussed as a living document in the twentieth century. More ofthat, and also of American and Russian constitutional order later.But for the moment, we will not leave the eighteenth century.Instead, having noted again that there were echoes of Montesquieu,witting and unwitting, in the retiring President’s remarks, let uscross the ocean to set out a view of constitutional order formed atabout the same time in offshore Europe.Earlier in his career, Edmund Burke had been a good friend tothe American cause, although not to all of its revolutionary aspects.In general, he was a supporter of constitutional order, even ifunwritten rather than written, perhaps. Certainly, in 1790, soonafter the outbreak of the French Revolution, he had described it as‘a revolution of doctrine and theoretic dogma’, the first such sincethe Reformation, and bound, like its predecessor, ‘to introduce otherinterests into all countries than those which arose from their localityand natural circumstances’. Thus, for example:The Russian Government is of all others the most liable tobe subverted by military seditions, by court conspiracies,and sometimes by headlong rebellions of the people, suchas the turbinating movements of Pugatchef. It is not quiteso probable that in any of these changes the spirit of systemmay mingle in the manner it has done in France. TheMuscovites are no great speculators—but I should notmuch rely on their uninquisitive disposition, if any of theirordinary motives to sedition should arise. The littlecatechism of the rights of man is soon learned; and theinfer-ences are in the passions.Six or so years on, and the situation had deteriorated almostbeyond recognition, as Burke was to spell out in his Letters on theProposals for Peace with the Regicide Directory of France. Many laterobservers would say that by 1796–7 the Republic was returning tosome kind of order, but not Burke at the time. In his view, since theRevolution, a state had prevailed worse than anarchy, for thegovernment had become ‘the most absolute, despotic, and effective’that had ever appeared on earth:Never were the views and politics of any governmentpursued with half the regularity, system, and method, thata diligent observer must have contemplated with amaze-ment and terror in theirs. Their state is not an anarchy, buta series of short-lived tyrannies.France had no public, and the French people had become absoluteslaves, in a manner ‘so searching, so penetrating, so heart-breaking’that nothing like it was known by ‘the helots of Laconia, theregardants of the manor in Russia and Poland, even the negroes inthe West Indies’.42In such conditions, Russian and other peasants were less likelyperhaps to be seduced by ‘the little catechism of the rights of man’,but Burke found it necessary, nevertheless, to develop furtheranalysis and issue more warnings. He looked with approval atthe past:There have been periods of time in which communities,apparently in peace with each other, have been moreperfectly separated than, in latter times, many nations ofEurope have been in the course of long and bloody wars.The cause must be sought in the similitude throughoutEurope of religion, laws and manners. At bottom, theseare all the same. The writers on public law have often calledthis aggregate of nations a commonwealth. They hadreason. It is virtually one great state having the same basisof general law, with some diversity of provincial customsand local establishments. The nations of Europe have hadthe very same Christian religion, agreeing in thefundamental parts, varying a little in the ceremonies andin the subordinate doctrines.It would seem, then, that the Reformation was no longer the greatrevolution in theory and doctrine that it had been for Burke in1790. In 1796–7, he continued:The whole of the polity and economy of every country inEurope has been derived from the same sources. It wasdrawn from the old Germanic or Gothic customary, fromthe feudal institutions which must be considered as anemanation from that customary; and the whole has beenimproved and digested into system and discipline by theRoman law. From hence arose the several orders, with orwithout a monarch (which are called states), in everyEuropean country; the strong trace of which, wheremonarchy predominated, were never wholly extinguishedor merged in despotism. In the few places where monarchywas cast off, the spirit of European monarchy was still left.Those countries still continued countries of states; that is,of classes, orders, and distinctions such as had beforesubsisted, or nearly so. Indeed the force and form of theinstitution called states continued in greater perfection inthose republican communities than under monarchies.Possibly Montesquieu might not have agreed with this lastobservation, but in general his spirit presided over the letters ofBurke, who went on to remark that Europe’s ‘system of mannersand of education’ was so similar throughout the continent that ‘nocitizen of Europe could be altogether an exile in any part of it...andnever felt himself quite abroad’.But now, ‘a general evil’ was to be found in every country ofEurope, and among all orders of men. The centre of the evil wasFrance, and the circumference was ‘the world of Europe whereverthe race of Europe may be settled’. Looking around this world,Burke lighted last on the most important of all, as he saw it—Russia, where he hoped that the Emperor Paul, the former GrandDuke who had succeeded Catherine the Great in 1796, wouldrule in the tradition of Peter the Great, since: ‘He is sensible thathis business is not to innovate, but to secure and to establish; thatreformations at this day are attempts at best of ambiguous utility.’Burke then went on to say: ‘I do not know why I should notinclude America among the European powers, because she is ofEuropean origin; and has not yet, like France, destroyed all traceof manners, laws, opinions, and usages, which she drew fromEurope.’ Nevertheless, an America ‘men-aced with internal ruinfrom the attempts to plant Jacobinism instead of liberty in thatcountry...whose independence is directly attacked by the French’was unwisely advocating ‘a treacherous peace’ with those Frenchforces threatening both peace and neutrality everywhere. ForFrance was bent on forming a universal empire through universalrevolution, and would attempt sooner or later to involve all othercountries in a war against Britain and the British constitution,destroying for ever the balance of power and artificially creatinga new constitution almost every year.43From Burke in 1797, let us move towards conclusion by way ofMontesquieu about half a century before. In The Spirit of the Laws,we found the classical exposition of constitutional order. Lookingback at the British Revolution of the seventeenth century,Montesquieu observed that the nobility was buried with CharlesI, and that Charles II believed himself to be less powerful than hisfather. On the other hand, he wrote:It was a fine spectacle in the last century to see the impo-tent attempts of the English to establish democracy amongthemselves. As those who took part in public affairs hadno virtue at all, as their ambition was excited by the successof the most audacious one [Cromwell] and the spirit ofone faction was repressed only by the spirit of another, thegovernment was constantly changing; the people, stunned,sought democracy and found it nowhere. Finally, aftermuch motion and many shocks and jolts, they had cometo rest on the very government that had been proscribed.44A monarchy without a nobility could hardly have been the same,but would promote more virtue than its regicide predecessor.Montesquieu would appear to have looked upon the seventeenth-century revolution, then, as Burke looked upon the revolution atthe end of the eighteenth century.Of course, we cannot say how Montesquieu would have reactedto events in France in 1789 and after. But we can observe that hismasterpiece, looked upon as subversive enough at the time of itspublication, was now considered for the most part a force forconservatism. Its argument that any polity should embody the spiritof its people was being replaced by the argument that the spirit should be changed, or at least more liber-ated. On the other hand,Marat declared in 1785 on the road to revolution that Montesquieuwas ‘the first among us to carry the torch of philosophy intolegislation, to avenge outraged humanity, to defend its rights, andin a way, to become the legislator for the whole world’. Generally,according to Anne M.Cohler: ‘In France, during and after the FrenchRevolution, Montesquieu’s concern to balance power led to thequestion of whether there remained any independent politicalbody, king, or noble, that could be used to moderate the sovereigntyof the people.’45Of course, the revolutionaries themselves in the years following1789 were too preoccupied with day-to-day events and too muchmen of affairs ever to set down in an extended form their ownview of the world. On the other hand, Robespierre at least wasable to express his broad outlook in a speech of 25 December 1793,which we have already encountered in the Introduction and whichwill now lead us from Chapter 1 towards Chapter 2:The theory of the revolutionary government is as new asthe revolution which has brought it to power. We mustnot look for it in the books of political writers, who by nomeans foresaw this revolution; nor in the laws of tyrantswho, content to abuse their power, are hardly preoccupiedwith investigating its legitimacy.... The function of thegovernment is to direct the moral and physical energies ofthe nation towards the goal for which it is instituted....The greater the power, the more free and rapid is its actionand the more necessary is it that good faith directs it; forthe day it falls into impure or perfidious hands, libertywill be lost; indeed, its name will become the pretext andexcuse of counter-revolution itself and its energy will bethat of a violent poison.46Constitution, revolution, counter-revolution, would the greatwheel never stop turning? On 5 February 1794, Robespierre triedto put forward ‘an exact theory and precise rules of conduct’, anew concept of virtue, ‘an order of things where all base and cruelpassions are bound up and all the benevolent and gen-erouspassions are aroused by the laws’. The people would be led byreason and the enemies of the people by terror in a situation whichwas as if ‘the two opposing spirits that have been contending forcontrol of nature are fighting, in this great epoch of human history,to establish irreversibly the history of the world, and France is thetheatre of this awesome combat’.47 The second speech was not theequal of the first. Robespierre was already in decline, and was tolose most coherence before his execution in late July 1794. Butopposing spirits of constitution and revolution, if not quite as hedefined them, would continue their struggle.Before moving on to Marx, let us see what we have done withMontesquieu. Without repeating the opening remarks of thischapter, let us simply note that The Spirit of the Laws has helped usto conduct a kind of laboratory test. Historians often talkmetaphorically of the litmus test, for example of the manner inwhich a tendency or movement may become more acidic— thatis, redder—or more alkaline—that is, bluer. Here, I shall use in asimilar way the more refined ‘universal indicator’ of the ‘pH test’.48That is, in drawing up their constitutions, the American FoundingFathers and the Russian Empress made use of the great work fortheir own purposes. Thus, Montesquieu’s book is the ‘neutral’: overthe Atlantic, American ‘alkali’ affected it in the creation of a basisfor the federal republic; over the continent, Russian ‘acid’ workedupon the emerging structure of enlightened absolutism. In this case,by ‘alkali’ I mean the inbuilt tendency in the USA towardsrepresentative government, ultimately democracy, the politicalculture formed by the immi-grants from Europe in their newsetting. On the other hand, I take ‘acid’ to be the political cultureevolving in Russia over the centuries in its particular environment.Thus, we have pointed out the relationship between Montesquieu’sWestern world order on the one hand and the stage reached at theend of the eighteenth century by Russian history and our selectedprincipal comparator, American history, on the other.Let us now proceed to conduct a similar experiment with Marxand his Capital

GEORGE WASHINGTON AND THE AMERICANCONSTITUTION

Genet arrived back in Paris in September. In almost no time at all,he made a considerable impression on the salon of Mme Roland,who spoke of his ‘solid’ and ‘enlightened mind’, and of the‘sweetness, justice, grace, and reason’ of his conversation, whichcontained no ‘affectation or pedantry’. Jacques Pierre Brissot, whohad recently visited the USA and written a book about it, used hisinfluence as a journalist and politician to advance the cause of‘democrat Genet’ as he chose to call him. Having written a reporton the reorganisation of the diplomatic service, arguing for itscomparability to the civil service, Genet found himself thebeneficiary of one of his own proposals, the substitution of‘Minister’ for ‘Ambassador’ as the highest appointment, as he wasappointed representative of the French government in the USAearly in November The instructions for Minister, or as he was to become known,Citizen Genet, were ready by the middle of December, and werein two parts, the first more rhetorical, the second more practical.They began with a misunderstanding of the Americanconstitution which was to lead to later complications: addressednot to the President, but to Congress, the instructions were basedon the erroneous belief that the American Congress, like theFrench National Convention, possessed all power since itembodied the sovereign will of the people. Genet seems to havebeen unable to eradicate this misconception during the monthsof his mission.Indeed Genet’s high-handed policies soon after his arrival inmid-May 1793 attracted much disquiet, and the Americangovernment decided to ask for his recall, complaining that theFrench Minister was acting in the USA as if he were a ‘co-sovereign’. Just one sentence in a long letter written by Jeffersonin mid-August aroused debate in the cabinet: the Secretary ofState feared that Genet’s activities might lead towards hostilitybetween the USA and France and bring upon both of them ‘areproach, which it is hoped will never stain the history of either,that of liberty warring on herself’. Alexander Hamilton, theleading member of the pro-British element in the Americanadministration, objected to the last four words, unable to acceptthat the course taken by the French Revolution made it possibleany longer to accept that it promoted liberty. Washington and asufficient number of members of the cabinet were persuaded thatthe four words should be deleted.36Soon after Genet learned of the request for his recall, in asituation deteriorating even further, he wrote in early October 1793an angry response giving emphasis to his own view of theAmerican constitution:Persuaded that the sovereignty of the United States residesessentially in the People and its representatives inCongress; persuaded that the Executive power is the onlyone which has been confided to the President of the UnitedStates; persuaded that this magistrate has not the right todecide questions... [which] the Constitution reservesparticularly to Congress; persuaded that he has not thepower to bend existing treaties to circumstances...per-suaded that the league formed by the tyrants to annihilate republican principles founded on the rights of man, willbe the object of the most serious deliberations of Congress;I had deferred in the sole view of maintaining goodharmony between the free people of America and France,communicating to my Government, before the epoch atwhich the representatives of the People were to assemble,the original correspondence which has taken place...between you and myself.37Less than six months after his arrival in the American capital,then, Genet had reached the point of no return in his relations withthe American administration. He had alienated himself from thegovernment in the USA even more quickly than he had previouslydone from that in Russia. However, on this occasion, unlike before,Genet did not go home, but married and settled down as a farmer,writing to his future wife early in 1794 that his ‘sole desire was tosettle in a country where virtue was honoured and liberty respected;where a man who obeyed the law had nothing to fear from despots,aristocrats, or ambitious men.’38 Red Indians and black slaves, toname but two groups, would not have agreed, but Genet’s decisionsas well as his letter to his future wife were a clear reflection on thetriangular relationship of constitutional developments in the USA,France and Russia in the 1790s.Of course, in that decade, the international situation as well asthe relative internal situation in each country were changing veryquickly, and, even in the USA, life was far from tranquil for politicalleaders. In the summer of 1793, which Jefferson consideredimportant for mankind all over the earth, President Washingtonlost his temper after a satirical attack in which it was suggestedthat he would suffer the same fate as Louis XVI. As Jeffersondescribed the ensuing spectacle:The President was much inflamed, got into one of thosepassions when he cannot command himself, ran on muchon the personal abuse which had been bestowed on him,defied any man on earth to produce one act of his since hehad been in the govmt. which had not been done on thepurest motives, that...by god he had rather be in his gravethan in his present situation. That he had rather be on hisfarm than to be made emperor of the world and yet they werecharging him with wanting to be a KingBy this time, early August, an outbreak of yellow fever hadbegun, and was to become an epidemic by the end of the month.Thus, climate interfered with the business of government as wellas affecting the tempers of its leaders, a vindication of some ofMontesquieu’s arguments in The Spirit of the Laws.However, rather than developing that point, looking further atpopular disaffection in 1793 and 1794 or examining the manner inwhich the great debates on the French Revolution continued inthe USA in the later 1790s, we will look at the comparative calm ofWashington’s famous Farewell Address of 19 September 1796,seeking out in particular the retiring Presi-dent’s views on theconstitutional order. Thanking his fellow-countrymen for theirsupport and expressing the wish that ‘the free constitution, whichis the work of your hands, may be sacredly maintained’,Washington went on to declare:Citizens by birth or choice of a common country, thatcountry has a right to concentrate your affections. Thename of AMERICAN, which belongs to you, in yournational capacity, must always exalt the just pride of Patri-otism, more than any appellation derived from local dis-criminations. With slight shades of difference, you havethe same Religion, Manners, Habits, and politicalPrinciples. You have in a common cause fought andtriumphed together. The Independence and Liberty youpossess are the work of joint councils, and joint efforts—or common dangers, sufferings and successes.Here is a blend of constitutional order with its antithesis,revolutionary order.However, the strong emphasis is on the preservation of whathad been won in the past rather than on what might be gained inthe future. And so, although ‘the right of the people to make andalter their Constitutions of Government’ is the basis of ourpolitical systems, change can only come about through ‘an explicitact of the whole people’. Until such a step has been taken,Washington stresses, the constitution which exists at any time ‘issacredly obligatory upon all’. To take another example, ‘thecontinuance of the UNION’ should be ‘a primary object ofPatriotic desire’. The President asked an almost rhetoricalquestion, possibly reflecting some of the reservations of Montesquieu as well as more recent debates: ‘Is there a doubt,whether a common government can embrace so large a sphere?’But his answer in fact left little room for doubt. Immediately, itwas: ‘Let experience solve it. To listen to mere speculation in sucha case were criminal.’ A longer response, arguing for the necessityof co-operation between North, South, East and West, took up anot insignificant proportion of the Farewell Address.The spirit of the American laws was expressed further through‘reciprocal checks in the exercise of political power’, obtained ‘bydividing and distributing it into different deposi-tories, andconstituting each the Guardian of the Public Weal againstinvasions by the others’. The necessity for such checks had beenevinced ‘by experiments ancient and modern; some of them inour country and under our own eyes’. Here again was a mixtureof old and not so old precept with more recent practice. Furtherprops for justice and efficiency (all of them noted by Montesquieuin his time) were the promotion of institutions for the generaldiffusion of knowledge, and the preservation through restraintof the public credit, not to mention religion and morality. Domesticdespotism would thus be avoided.Internally, apart from threats to the Union, there were ‘thebaneful effects of the Spirit of Party, generally’. Unfortunately,this spirit was natural and deep-rooted, and was sharpened byanother spirit, that of revenge. In different ages and countries,there had thus arisen a frightful despotism, which could leadthrough an inclination ‘to seek security and repose in theabsolute power of an Individual’ to ‘a more formal andpermanent despotism’. Party might serve as a useful check ongovernment and protection of liberty in monarchies, but wasnot a spirit to be encouraged in those which were purely electiveand of a popular character.Externally, peace and harmony should be cultivated with allnations, while ‘inveterate antipathies against particular nationsand passionate attachments for others should be excluded’. Inparticular, Washington observed that ‘Europe has a primary setof interests, which to us have none, or a very remote relation.Hence she must be engaged in frequent controversies, the causesof which are essentially foreign to our concerns.’ At the same time:‘Our detached and distant situation invites and enables us topursue a different course.’ And so: ‘Why, by interweaving ourdestiny with that of any part of Europe, entangle our peace and prosperity, in the toils of European ambition, rivalship, interest,humour, or caprice?

carried out by force of arms. However, the aim was not to harmthe reasonable liberty of individuals, but to abolish a governmentin the form of a republic incompatible with the existence of a greatkingdom, all the more because it was contrary to the wishes of thenation prescribed in the cahiers (statements of public opinion) forthe maintenance of monarchical government and the RomanCatholic religion.The deliverance of the king and royal family must be carriedout in a manner least likely to cause the risk of a revolt of the princeswhich would plunge France into open civil war. Calm andtranquillity should be reborn from the provinces, whose harmonywould oblige the capital to follow their example. Moreover, asmonarchical government was being re-established, old customswhich inspired respect for rank among the public should not beneglected or despised. Soldiers must always wear their uniform incamp, while persons of superior standing should not appear inpublic without their appropriate dress, nor princes allow anybodyinto their presence in similar circumstances. Such measures woulddiscourage any lingering illusion of perfect equality, and introduceanew the dignity of rank in military and civil life, along with thecertainty of hierarchy in the three estates. Generally speaking,Catherine was aiming in her measures for the restoration of thekind of monarchy favoured by Montesquieu, true to the Frankishheritage as set out at length in Part 6 of The Spirit of the Laws, andreflected by French public opinion in the cahiers: that is, absolutemonarchy, but constitutional. She also revealed some of her ownbureau-cratic-autocratic outlook.31After the radical turn in the French Revolution signalled by theexecution of the king and queen early in 1793, Catherine’s hopesfor restoration were dashed, and her disillusionment with thecourse of events moved towards horror. About a year later, inFebruary 1794, she wrote to Baron Melchior von Grimm:And so you were right, never expressing the wish to beincluded among the luminaries, the illuminĂ©s and thephilosophes, since experience proves that all this leads todestruction; but whatever they have said and done, theworld will never cease to heed an authority...it is better toprefer the foolishness of one, than the madness of many,infecting with fury twenty million people in the name of‘freedom’, of which they do not possess even the shadow

 after which these madmen rush forward to ensure that itwill never be achieved.32Catherine’s final position, then, was even more absolute, and lessconstitutional.Her far-sighted correspondent, Baron von Grimm, had made along-term forecast of the French Revolution’s impact at the end of1790, writing of a future when:Two empires will then share all the advantages ofcivilisation, of the power of genius, of letters, arts, armsand industry: Russia on the eastern side, and America,having become free in our own time, on the western side,and we other peoples of the nucleus will be too degraded,too debased, to know otherwise than by a vague and stupidtradition what we have been.33The quality of Grimm’s forecast was adversely affected byanother of its features, his declaration that the French Revolutionwould mean the end of Europe, rather than leading towards thecontinent’s further ascendancy. We can compare the actual impactof the French Revolution on the transcontinental and transoceanicfrontiers by considering successive episodes in the career of a singleindividual. Edmond Charles Genet was born early in 1763 atVersailles, a location aptly suggesting the background ofcomfortable circumstances, even if bourgeois rather thanaristocratic. An ambitious father pushed him towards a careernormally above his station, in diplomacy, and after an appropriateeducation including a version of the Grand Tour, followed by someyears in the civil service, he was appointed Secretary of the Legationin the St Petersburg Embassy. Arriving at the beginning of 1788, hebecame chargĂ© d’affaires in 1789 when the Ambassador returned toFrance soon after the outbreak of the Revolution.At first, Genet was taken aback, writing at the beginning of1790 that ‘We have shown Europe the sad sight of all those illsbrought about by anarchy.’ By July 1791, his position had shiftedconsiderably, as was shown by some of his comments ondevelopments in Poland: ‘For a long time I could not assimilatethe direction of the new constitution. The consequences ofrevolution frightened me, but now I am completely attached tothat system which the people have chosen.’ Later in the same year, he exclaimed: ‘The more numerous the enemies of freedom,the stronger burns the flame of my patriotism.’ He wrote to hissister:I am a patriot not from calculation, but from goodconscience, as always. I love freedom, hate violence, andthe rules of my conduct are based on the citizen’s oath. I amtrue to the last breath to the law, the nation and the king.Towards the end of 1791, there was some doubt in Genet’s mind,and he wrote: ‘If we cannot instil respect for our order, then it mustbe abandoned.’ But he soon recovered to reiterate: ‘My conductwill show that it is possible to love freedom and to worship theking.’ He thus confirmed an earlier instruction to his sister: ‘Informthe king of my feeling and tell him that I shall spill my blood forhis defence with as much readiness as in defence of theconstitution.’ Just before his departure from St Petersburg, Genetobserved in July 1792: ‘Hereditary constitutional monarchy is thebest way of opposing the disastrous intervention of foreigners.’34Catherine opposed what she saw as his disastrous interventionby ordering him to leave in July 1792. His moderate support of theFrench Revolution, even though not far from her own originalattitude towards it, was too much for her.